Python partial and placeholders

When Python 3.14 was released I had already read about some of its main features (those that involve a PEP and that have been discussed in the Python discussion forums), like Lazy Annotations and Template Strings. When reading in depth recently the release notes I came across a small feature added to functools.partial (and partialmethod) that I find particularly useful:

functools:
Add the Placeholder sentinel. This may be used with the partial() or partialmethod() functions to reserve a place for positional arguments in the returned partial object. (Contributed by Dominykas Grigonis in gh-119127.)

Just a reminder of what partial function application is (don't confuse it with the related concept of curried functions):

In computer science, partial application (or partial function application) refers to the process of fixing a number of arguments of a function, producing another function of smaller arity.

Indeed I already talked about functools.partial some time ago

The "basic" approach to partial function application is that we can just fix (pre-fill) arguments from left to right. This is what we have also in JavaScript with function.prototype.bind (that binds as first argument the "this" value). As Python supports named arguments, functools.partial already supported fixing named arguments.

def format_geo_info(country, region, city, population):
    return f"{city}, {region.upper()} ({country}) - {population}"
    
bound_format = functools.partial(format_geo_info, "France")
print(bound_format("Occitanie", "Toulouse", 500_000))
# Toulouse, OCCITANIE (France) - 500000
print(bound_format("Occitanie", city="Toulouse", population=500_000))
# Toulouse, OCCITANIE (France) - 500000

What was not possible until this version was fixing some intermediate non-named argument, but this is possible since version 3.14 thanks to the Placehodler sentinel value:

format_french_city_with_unknown_population = partial(format_geo_info, "France", Placeholder, Placeholder, 0)
print(format_french_city_with_unknown_population("Ile de France", "Saint Denis"))
# Saint Denis, ILE DE FRANCE (France) - 0

Not a revolutionary feature, but one that I've missed occasionally. A trivial implementation could be something like this:

# supports positional and keyword arguments, but not placeholders
def my_basic_partial(func, *args, **kwargs):
    return lambda *fargs, **fkwargs: func(*args, *fargs, **(kwargs | fkwargs))
    
# add support for placeholders in the arguments
PLACEHOLDER = object()
def my_complete_partial(func, *args, **kwargs):
    def new_func(*fargs, **fkwargs):
        merged_args = []
        fargs_iter = iter(fargs)
        for arg in args:
            if arg is PLACEHOLDER:
                merged_args.append(next(fargs_iter))
            else:
                merged_args.append(arg)
        merged_args.extend(fargs_iter)
        return func(*merged_args, **(kwargs | fkwargs))
    return new_func

format_french_city_with_unknown_population = my_complete_partial(format_geo_info, "France", PLACEHOLDER, PLACEHOLDER, 0)
print(format_french_city_with_unknown_population("Ile de France", "Saint Denis"))
# Saint Denis, ILE DE FRANCE (France) - 0

format_2 = my_complete_partial(format_geo_info, "France", city="Toulouse")
print(format_2("Occitanie", population=500_000))
# Toulouse, OCCITANIE (France) - 500000

In my aforementioned previous post about partial in Python I gave some reasons for using partial over directly trapping the variables with a closure (of course internally partial has to use either closures or a callable class). I've just realised that I was missing the main reason, partial is more semantic.

- Intent-Revealing Code: partial(func, arg) explicitly states your intent to partially apply arguments, improving readability and self-documentation. - Declarative Style: It focuses on the result (a new specialized function) rather than the imperative mechanics of capturing lexical scope.

Lodash, the excellent JavaScript library, also features placeholders in its implemention of partial.